Episode 44: “New Soil, New Roots” - Part Two (featuring Brian Fisher)
Telling stories of turning transition into transformation. There is Life After Ministry.
Is the Church Missing the Mark on Discipleship?
Why is it that modern churches seem so successful in introducing people to Jesus but struggle to lead them into a life of true transformation?
Brian Fisher doesn’t hold back as he has done a deep dive on how there is something missing in the church experience: a failure to address the deeper stages of discipleship.
Drawing from his own journey through loss, reflection, and rebuilding, Brian shares his vision for a radically different approach: smaller, intimate communities focused on spiritual formation instead of surface-level engagement.
In this episode, Brian and Matt discuss how “the wall” in the discipleship journey forces us to confront our brokenness and deepen our relationship with Christ.
And Brian introduces the Soil & Roots concept of “Greenhouses,” spaces designed to cultivate deep spiritual growth, and how they differ from traditional small groups.
For anyone longing to go beyond the basics of faith, this episode is a must-listen.
Key Points
The Wall and Wilderness: Moving through disorientation is painful, but it’s necessary for deeper growth in Christ.
Reimagining Discipleship: The first three stages of faith—knowing, learning, and serving—are just the beginning. True transformation happens in stages four, five, and six.
The Greenhouse Model: Unlike most small groups, greenhouses foster safety, intimacy, and authentic wrestling with God’s truths.
The Church’s Blind Spot: Modern church structures often focus on attracting crowds but neglect the messy, time-consuming work of deep spiritual formation.
Hope After Ministry: Brian’s story shows there is life and ministry after vocational leadership—if we’re willing to redefine success on God’s terms.
Pull Quotes
"Churches are great at making converts but struggle to make disciples who think, act, and love like Jesus."
"True spiritual formation happens in the wilderness, not in the crowd."
"The church should grow smaller, not bigger, if we want to see real transformation."
"The wall isn’t a punishment—it’s an invitation into God’s deeper love."
Chapter Markers
0:00 – 2:02: The Church’s Failure in Stages Four, Five, and Six of Discipleship
2:03 – 5:35: What Is a Greenhouse? Introducing the Model for Deep Spiritual Growth
5:36 – 8:29: Why Most Small Groups Aren’t Enough for Real Formation
8:30 – 10:49: The Power Struggles in Church Institutions and Why They Resist Change
10:50 – 13:37: Wrestling with Faith: The Importance of Vulnerability in Community
13:38 – 15:46: Gratitude for the Wilderness: Finding Joy in Suffering
15:47 – 19:52: Dredging the Depths: Removing Debris to Create New Life
19:53 – 22:38: Becoming Deeper People: Awake to God, Others, Ourselves, and Creation
22:39 – 24:54: Inviting People Into the Deep End of Discipleship
24:55 – 26:54: Connecting with Soil and Roots
Want to Go Deeper?
Brian’s insights challenge us to rethink what it means to truly follow Jesus. Whether you’re longing for deeper community, wrestling with your faith, or navigating a wilderness season, this episode provides hope and practical guidance.
Website: SoilandRoots.org
Podcast: Soil and Roots (Available on all platforms)
Substack: Search Soil and Roots for in-depth articles on discipleship
This is part two of Brian’s story. Together with part one, it paints a compelling vision for what the church could become if we embraced the call to deeper discipleship.
Find resources. Find hope.
This is a sanctuary for those who've experienced a transition out of church or nonprofit Christian leadership roles. Our mission is to provide a platform for sharing, learning, and growing through each other's experiences.
A place for elders needing answers.
Welcome to the Elder Hub, a platform designed to uplift, empower, and unite elders across Christian denominations. This group serves as support and guidance for those entrusted with the weighty responsibility of making critical decisions within churches and nonprofit ministries.
